While I’ve had a blast exploring the 2011 Core Set, I can’t say I’m anywhere near as excited about the latest MTG expansion, Scars of Mirrodin. I’m sure JB would be disappointed, but I just can’t help it.
I’ve browsed the visual spoiler and while there are certainly a few stand outs for me, the set as a whole isn’t ringing my bell. Why? For starters it’s a throwback to the original Mirrodin block it would seem- a set I’m completely unfamiliar with as a relative noob in Magic. I’m sure that set must’ve had a pretty big impact on players at the time for them to revisit it here, but sadly, I wasn’t one of them.
Lacking the ability to connect with the nostalgic aside, I have at least gathered that the set is centered highly around artifacts. There are definitely some artifacts I’ve enjoyed success with, but not to the point that I’ve gotten around to building an entire deck around them. I’ll admit I picked up the new duel deck, Elspeth vs. Tezzeret but I haven’t had a chance to play with them. It’s possible they may yet change my opinion on artifact-heavy decks but we’ll have to see.
I’m also not particularly fond of having poison counters featured so prominently. I understand that when you’ve got a TCG that’s maintained the kind of popularity that Magic has for 15 years you might need to revisit a safe mechanic if only for a breather before the next big thing, but poison counters always seemed kind of cheap to me. Unless the rules have changed, if you can put 10 poison counters on an opponent they lose, which is almost like reducing their life to 10 from the onset of the game in my book and believe me, there’s no shortage of creatures dealing poison counters in Scars of Mirrodin.
Maybe I’m just getting elitest after being spoiled by so many wonderful cards from Zendikar, but I just don’t seem to be getting into this one. I’ll probably still do some drafts just to see if I eat my words and maybe get the fat pack, but I can’t see myself splitting boxes of the set with friends either.
How do you feel about Scars of Mirrodin?